The ProSure Group

About The ProSure Group

The ProSure Group, Inc., was organized in 1993 by David B. Shick and is headquartered in Tampa, Florida. We are now one of the leading surety agencies in the Southeastern U.S., representing some of the largest and most respected insurers in the world. Our initial growth came primarily through serving the bond needs of the construction industry, and we continue to issue hundreds of millions of dollars in construction bonds annually.

Over the years we have expanded to provide other lines of bonds and fidelity insurance. Hundreds of financial institutions, auto dealers, agricultural product dealers, law firms, insurance agencies and medical care providers depend on ProSure to bridge their bond needs to respectable, reliable providers. Throughout this growth we have upheld – and refined – a simple but powerful formula: to provide knowledgeable, understanding and creative surety services through an excellent and educated team of professionals while using state-of-the-art technology. As we move forward, we will continue to refine our efforts, maintaining acuity for the surety bond industry while providing our clients with insight and understanding that can help their businesses survive, stabilize and grow.

Consistently Rated 5 Stars In These Categories


Timeliness and Easy Process

Our goal is to provide you with simple and efficient service so you can focus on your business while we make sure your suppliers are dependable.


Knowledgeable Assistance

We simplify legal terms in order to guarantee that you know exactly what your bond entails. We also respond to any questions you may have in a timely manner.


Good Communication

As one of the leading surety agencies in the Southeastern U.S. we pride ourselves in our knowledge of a variety of bonds to make sure you get the respectable providers you need for your business.


Overall Experience

With over 25 years of experience, we have expanded our focus on the construction industry to provide you with dependable bonds for all of your business needs.

David B. Shick


David's experience in the surety industry extends back to 1989... having spent time on the carrier/underwriting side and the broker/agency side of the surety business, David's entrepreneurial spirit drove him to start The ProSure Group in 1993. With customer-focused determination, creativity, resourcefulness, and a competitive drive, he's guided the company from scratch to becoming an industry leader. David now continues to maintain the position of President of The ProSure Group. He is a graduate of the University of South Florida with a degree in Finance where he also worked on his MBA, a father of two girls and a loving husband. On a personal level, he is a dedicated family man. He spends much of his spare time as a Fast-pitch softball coach.

Steven Schumacher

Vice President, Underwriting

Steven's experience in the surety industry extends all the way back to 1987...having spent time on the carrier/underwriting side and the broker/agency side of the surety business. Steven's knowledge, experience, creativity and attention to detail plays a vital role in his success and the Company's success. Steven maintains the position of Vice President, Underwriting at The ProSure Group. He is a graduate of the University of Colorado and earned his MBA at the University of Tampa. A father of two boys, Steven spends his spare time with his family and shares his talents as a bass guitarist with The Urbane Cowboys, an alt-country band that has seen its share of accolades and has been voted "Best Band" in many venues.

Brandy Baich

Surety Executive

Brandy’s experience in the surety bond industry goes back to 1996, working on both the agency and insurance company side. This has given her a wealth of experience with commercial, contract, and court bonds (domestic and international). She has a reputation for being a very hard-working surety bond professional that goes the “extra mile” for clients. Brandy was born and raised in Arizona. She studied accounting and finance at Phoenix College and moved to Florida in 2014. She is a devoted wife and mother. Brandy spends her free time at the beach, savoring new food and wine, and going to concerts.


Gary Jessup

Court & Fidelity Bond Manager

Gary holds a BA in Communications. He has more than 25 years of business management experience in a variety of industries, including a strong background in sales & marketing. He began his career with Hyatt Hotels in Chicago, Illinois as a bellman & doorman during college and finally as the Director of Guest Services. Gary has worked as an opening specialist, traveling from location to location managing the opening teams for businesses in Chicago, New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, and Florida. Gary has spent the last 30 years as a manager, executive, or consultant helping to build the bottom lines for the companies he has worked with. He utilizes this wide array of business experience to help grow the business here at The ProSure Group, Inc. Gary is the father of 3 daughters and enjoys the outdoors, fishing both ocean and lakes as often as possible.

Anne Cerniglio

Director of Finance

Along with lots of personality, Annie is an accomplished and a highly qualified professional who brings a wealth of experience and knowledge in the areas of accounting, management, and system administration. Originally from Yonkers, NY, Annie has more than 25 years of experience with companies large and small across the Northeastern U.S., including White Plains, NY, New York City, Stamford, CT, and Philadelphia, PA. Annie is a passionate dog lover, she has four rescue pups and in addition she is an avid New York sports fan.

Danielle Whalen

CSR Commercial Bonds

Danielle is a very hard-working business professional that brings valuable experience from her diverse background of employment. Raised in Bradenton, she moved to Tampa to start a new career path. She joined Prosure Group in 2014 as an Administrative Assistant and quickly proved her worth. She was promoted to work in the Commercial Bond Department and is now a leading producer. She enjoys the fast pace; ever-changing bond world, and her customer service is second to none. Danielle is a loving wife and cat mom. She loves to travel and when she isn’t out exploring new cities/countries, you can find her spending time with her niece or the rest of her big family.

Alyssa King

Marketing Director

Alyssa brings a lot of passion when it comes to working at the ProSure Group since her father started the business when she was four. After graduating high school, Alyssa ventured out to pursue her college degree. She received her Associate’s of Arts degree from Santa Fe college in Gainesville where she lived for about 3 years. After receiving her AA, she headed to South Florida where she continued her education in Boca Raton at Florida Atlantic University and got her Bachelor’s of Science degree in Business. Alyssa had several different jobs in South Florida in the field of marketing, gaining her a lot of experience. Alyssa is a loving wife with two daughters and enjoys meeting new people, everything outdoors, and traveling.

Melanie R. Mullis

CSR Contract Bonds

Melanie is a Cum Laude graduate of St. Petersburg College, Majoring in Business Administration with a Minor in Management. Melanie has been with The ProSure Group, Inc. since 2015. Her background has been in customer service and organization. She is extremely organized! Melanie has been learning the Surety Industry from the ground up and has proven to be a quick learner. She was born and raised in Safety Harbor, this makes her a true Florida native. Melanie is happily married and enjoys spending her free time outdoors, she especially enjoys gardening.

Nate O’Brien

Administrative Assistant

Nate holds a B.A in Business Management from the University of South Florida. He has 10+ years of a combination of military and professional experience. Nate is a self-starter and fast learner who is dedicated to fulfilling the needs of both the customer and company. As a devoted husband and father of two girls, Nate spends most of his free time enjoying quality experiences with his family.

Memberships and Associations

Gulf Coast Builders Exchange Logo
Blue Book Logo Qualify Us Now! ProView
Suncoast Utility Contractors Association
Florida Transportation Builders' Association Inc
Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. Member
Florida Surety Assocation